RentPrep Review: Pricing, Features, Pros & Cons

Profile image for Katie Kistler
Katie Kistler
Updated 13 min read
Used by more than 1 million, including the most trusted names in real estate
related-logo-png lincon-property-logo-png lennar-logo-png CA-ventures-logo bozzuto-logo-png

Key takeaways:

  • RentPrep charges per report: Credit Report Only and Background Check Only cost $29 each, Complete costs $49, and income add-ons cost $10–$15.
  • Credit Report Only is automated, while Background Check Only and Complete include FCRA-certified human review, which can take longer for complex records.
  • RentPrep supports small landlords and larger operators, but Enterprise full-credit access requires 50 or more units and an inspected commercial office.

 

Disclaimer: ButterflyMX provides these blog posts to help our customers and potential customers make the right business decisions. Our blog posts are based on the information available to us at the time of writing.

 

RentPrep is a tenant-screening service for landlords and property managers who need credit, background, eviction, identity, and optional income information before approving an applicant. This RentPrep review covers current pricing, package differences, coverage, turnaround, and the buyers each option may suit.

The key choice is between faster automated credit screening and background screening with a human review layer. You should also consider state-specific coverage, who will pay the fee, and how much effort applicants must put into the process.

This guide will answer:

 

Watch how ButterflyMX works:

 

 

What is RentPrep?

RentPrep is a U.S. tenant-screening service that provides credit reports, background checks, eviction searches, identity checks, and optional income and employment checks. It helps landlords evaluate applicants; it is not a physical access-control or security system.

Founded in 2007 as Fidelis Screening Solutions, RentPrep operates legally as Fidelis Asset Management, LLC. Roofstock acquired RentPrep in August 2022, and reports are now ordered and managed through Roofstock’s Stessa platform.

RentPrep says it has served more than 150,000 landlords and completed more than 2 million screenings. Those figures show scale, but they do not establish whether the service is the right fit for every property.

RentPrep covers pre-lease screening. ButterflyMX serves a different need: managing physical property access through video intercoms, access control, mobile access, and visitor access.

 

Who is RentPrep designed for?

Standard packages suit independent landlords and small-to-midsize property managers who prefer to pay only when they screen an applicant. Enterprise is for operators with at least 50 rental units and more complex workflow needs.

 

How does RentPrep tenant screening work?

Landlords create an online account, add the property and applicant, select a package, and send an authorization link. The applicant completes identity and consent steps before RentPrep can run the report.

Reports are delivered through Stessa. For income or employment screening, the applicant must also connect a bank account or payroll provider. That can add useful financial context, but it also adds a step that may slow completion.

 

Automated reports vs. human-reviewed reports

Credit Report Only uses TransUnion SmartMove to provide a credit report, bankruptcies, and ResidentScore. ResidentScore is a rental-risk score, not a traditional FICO score. The credit pull is a soft inquiry, so it does not lower the applicant’s credit score.

Background Check Only and Complete add FCRA-certified human review. Screeners compare identity details and review criminal, eviction, sex-offender, judgment, lien, and bankruptcy records instead of relying only on an automated database match.

Human review may help identify mismatched or incomplete records, but it does not guarantee an error-free report. It can also take longer when records involve several courts or jurisdictions.

 

RentPrep packages and features

RentPrep offers three standard packages and a custom Enterprise option. The packages do not all include the same information, so buyers should choose based on the records they need.

Swipe to compare →

Package Price Key reports Review method Who can pay Best fit
Credit Report Only $29 TransUnion credit report, ResidentScore, and bankruptcies Automated Landlord or tenant Buyers focused on credit and rental-risk data
Background Check Only $29 SSN and identity checks, criminal and sex-offender records, evictions, judgments, liens, and bankruptcies FCRA-certified human review Landlord only Landlords who need background records without a full credit report
Complete Screening Package $49 Credit Report Only plus the human-reviewed background check Automated credit data plus human-reviewed background records Landlord or tenant Buyers who want the broadest standard package
Enterprise Screening Custom High-volume screening, tiered workflows, dedicated support, applicant-pay options, and Taz API access Depends on configuration Custom options Qualifying operators with 50 or more units

 

Who pays the screening fee?

Credit Report Only and Complete can be paid by the landlord or applicant. Background Check Only is landlord-pay only. Landlords who pass the fee to applicants should also consider applicable state and local application-fee rules.

 

How much does RentPrep cost?

RentPrep charges $29 for Credit Report Only, $29 for Background Check Only, and $49 for Complete. Standard packages are pay per report, not a monthly subscription.

Income Verification costs $10, and Income and Employment Verification costs $15. These add-ons raise the total per-applicant cost and require the applicant to link bank or payroll information.

Enterprise pricing is not public. RentPrep describes Enterprise as a custom option for portfolios with at least 50 units.

 

Why older RentPrep prices differ

Some older reviews show lower prices than RentPrep’s current $29–$49 standard range. For example, iPropertyManagement’s RentPrep comparison and SoftwareOasis’s RentPrep comparison cite prices around $21–$40. Treat those amounts as historical pricing rather than current offers.

 

Accuracy, coverage, and turnaround time

RentPrep markets results in about one hour for straightforward cases, but human-reviewed or multi-jurisdiction reports may take longer. A competitor-authored comparison estimates one to two business days for some human-reviewed reports, so that range should not be read as a standard RentPrep timeline.

Swipe to compare →

Decision factor What RentPrep offers Condition Buyer implication
Human review Manual review by FCRA-certified screeners on Background Check Only and Complete Complex records may take longer Useful if record review matters more than instant-only delivery
Credit screening Automated TransUnion report and ResidentScore It is separate from the human-reviewed background check Choose Complete if you need both credit and background information
Criminal-history coverage Criminal searches in Background Check Only and Complete SmartMove automated criminal coverage varies by state Review the current package scope for the property’s location
Income checks Optional bank- or payroll-based reports Costs $10–$15 and requires applicant participation Plan for added cost and possible delays

 

State-level criminal-history coverage

State law can change what an automated screening product returns. A RentPrep list dated October 2024 identified roughly 24 states plus Washington, DC, where SmartMove automated criminal-history reporting was excluded. That list provides dated context, not a permanent map of coverage.

In affected states, landlords may need the separate human-reviewed background package instead of relying on SmartMove-related automated data. This matters most when choosing between Credit Report Only and Complete.

 

What human review changes

Human review can help distinguish an applicant from someone with a similar name and add context to records from multiple sources. The tradeoff is that court access, jurisdiction, and record complexity can affect delivery time.

Errors can occur in any consumer report. For wider context, TransUnion’s rental-screening unit reached a $15 million FTC and CFPB settlement in 2023 involving inaccurate eviction records. The action involved TransUnion, not RentPrep, but it shows why applicants and landlords should review adverse information carefully.

 

Enterprise screening and integrations

RentPrep Enterprise is for property managers and owners with at least 50 rental units. It offers custom pricing, a dedicated representative, tiered screening, applicant-pay options, and the Taz API for connecting screening data with proprietary leasing software.

Meeting the unit threshold does not automatically provide full-credit access. RentPrep says qualifying operators need an inspected commercial office with signage, a separate entryway, and appropriate security. That can exclude home-based or virtual operators, even when they manage enough units.

An independent review lists connections with AppFolio, Buildium, Entrata, and Yardi. Because that claim comes from a third party, buyers should ask about the connection and workflow for their specific software. The directly described Taz API is available through Enterprise.

Large operators may need both applicant screening and a physical access platform. RentPrep supports screening workflows, while ButterflyMX can manage building, gate, elevator, vehicle, visitor, and mobile access.

 

RentPrep pros, cons, and customer feedback

RentPrep is a stronger fit for buyers who want pay-per-report screening and the option of human-reviewed background records. The main tradeoffs are higher current prices than some older reviews show, possible delays from manual review, location-dependent automated coverage, and extra applicant effort for income checks.

 

RentPrep pros

  • Human-reviewed background reports: Manual review may reduce the risk of acting on a simple database mismatch.
  • No standard monthly subscription: Occasional screeners pay when they process an applicant.
  • Soft credit inquiry: Credit screening does not lower an applicant’s credit score.
  • Flexible payer options: Credit Report Only and Complete can be landlord- or tenant-paid where local rules allow.
  • Enterprise workflow support: Qualifying portfolios can use a dedicated representative and the Taz API.

 

RentPrep cons

  • Current prices exceed older published figures: Buyers may pay more than they expect if they rely on stale comparisons.
  • Human review can add time: Complex reports may not suit a workflow that needs an immediate decision.
  • Automated criminal coverage varies: Location can change which package provides the needed records.
  • Income checks add cost and friction: Applicants must connect financial or payroll data and complete extra steps.
  • Enterprise has an office requirement: Some home-based or virtual operators may not qualify for full-credit access.

RentPrep also promotes an internal retrospective result of up to 25% fewer tenant defaults. Because this is a vendor-reported result rather than an independent performance benchmark, buyers should not treat it as a guaranteed outcome.

 

RentPrep customer feedback

Long-time landlord comments on BiggerPockets mention generally fast core reports, fair pricing at the time, and responsive support. One contributor considered an optional verification add-on poor value, which is useful context but does not represent every customer’s experience.

RentPrep’s reviews page listed a 4.7 out of 5 Google rating from 185 reviews as of July 2024. Investopedia also included RentPrep among leading tenant-screening services. Ratings and editorial recognition can show sentiment, but they do not prove that an individual report will be complete or accurate.

 

Who should consider RentPrep?

RentPrep may suit independent landlords who screen occasionally, property managers who value a human review layer, and qualifying 50-plus-unit operators that need an API or dedicated support. Buyers who prioritize instant automation, bundled property-management tools, or fewer applicant steps should compare alternatives.

Screening ends once the applicant decision is made. A property may use RentPrep for tenant selection and ButterflyMX for ongoing resident, visitor, vehicle, package, and building access.

 

What happens if a RentPrep report is wrong?

The dispute channel depends on where the error appears. Background-report disputes go to RentPrep, while credit-report and ResidentScore disputes go to TransUnion because the companies handle separate consumer-reporting functions.

RentPrep operates legally as Fidelis Asset Management, LLC. The FCRA dispute process described by The Kim Law Firm allows up to 30 days for a background-report reinvestigation. Applicants should identify whether the disputed item is in the background or credit section before contacting the reporting agency.

  • Criminal, eviction, identity, or other background item: Use the RentPrep consumer dispute process.
  • Credit report or ResidentScore item: Submit the dispute to TransUnion.
  • Items in both sections: Separate disputes may be necessary because each agency is responsible for its own data.

 

RentPrep alternatives

The best alternative depends on whether you value automation, broader property-management tools, a different price structure, or a different applicant workflow.

Alternative Screening approach Why consider it
TransUnion SmartMove Automated, applicant-initiated screening For buyers who prioritize instant automated reports without RentPrep’s human review layer
CoreLogic MyRental Tiered screening packages Reported packages around $25–$38 make it useful for price and database-coverage comparisons
Avail Tenant Screening Screening within a broader property-management product Useful for landlords who also want rent collection and maintenance workflows
RentSpree Screening Automated reports for agent and higher-volume workflows Relevant when speed and an agent-oriented process are priorities
Clara digital passport screening Competitor-positioned instant screening with a free-to-landlord model Worth comparing when automation, applicant fraud checks, and landlord cost are central concerns

No option is universally best. Compare exact report contents, state coverage, payer options, turnaround expectations, applicant steps, and software workflow before choosing.

 

RentPrep vs. ButterflyMX

RentPrep and ButterflyMX are not direct substitutes. RentPrep helps property teams evaluate applicants before a lease, while ButterflyMX helps authorized people, residents, and visitors enter a property after access rights are assigned.

Swipe to compare →

Feature RentPrep ButterflyMX Why it matters
Primary function Provides credit, background, eviction, identity, and optional income screening reports Provides a property access and security platform for multifamily, commercial, gated, student-housing, and other properties One supports applicant evaluation; the other manages property entry and security workflows
User workflow Landlords order reports, and applicants complete identity, consent, and optional financial-linking steps online Authorized users can use mobile access for supported entrances, while residents can see and speak with visitors through a video intercom before granting remote entry The products serve different points in the resident journey
Physical access RentPrep is a web-based screening service, not an entry-management system Supports video intercoms, access control, mobile and visitor access, vehicle access control, and elevator controls Properties managing doors, gates, garages, or elevators need an access platform rather than a screening report
Platform breadth Portfolio capabilities focus on applicant reports, Stessa-based management, and an Enterprise screening API Brings access products together with security cameras, package rooms, smart lock integrations, and wallet-based credentials Teams can assess screening and ongoing property operations as separate needs that may work together

 

Frequently asked questions

 

How much does RentPrep cost?

RentPrep costs $29 for Credit Report Only, $29 for Background Check Only, and $49 for Complete. Income Verification costs $10, Income and Employment Verification costs $15, and Enterprise pricing is custom.

 

Is RentPrep a subscription?

No. Standard RentPrep packages are pay per report and do not require a recurring monthly screening subscription.

 

Does RentPrep perform a hard credit check?

No. RentPrep credit screening uses a soft inquiry, so it does not lower the applicant’s credit score.

 

How long does a RentPrep report take?

RentPrep markets results in roughly one hour for straightforward cases, but human-reviewed or complex multi-jurisdiction reports may take longer. The timeline depends on the package and records involved.

 

Does RentPrep check criminal history in every state?

Criminal-history availability varies by package and state. SmartMove automated criminal coverage has had state-level exclusions, so some landlords may need RentPrep’s separate human-reviewed background check.

 

Who pays for RentPrep screening?

Credit Report Only and Complete can be paid by the landlord or tenant, while Background Check Only is landlord-pay only. Local application-fee rules may affect whether a landlord can pass the cost to an applicant.

 

Can an applicant dispute a RentPrep report?

Yes. Background-report disputes go to RentPrep, while credit-report and ResidentScore disputes go to TransUnion. A RentPrep background reinvestigation may take up to 30 days.

 

Who owns RentPrep?

Fidelis Asset Management, LLC operates RentPrep. Roofstock acquired the company in August 2022, and RentPrep reports are now delivered through Stessa.

 

Is RentPrep suitable for large property managers?

Yes, if the operator meets Enterprise requirements. Enterprise targets portfolios with at least 50 units and offers custom pricing, dedicated support, tiered workflows, and Taz API access; full-credit access also requires an eligible commercial office.

 

Is RentPrep right for your property?

RentPrep belongs on the shortlist for occasional screeners who prefer pay-per-report pricing and for property managers who value human-reviewed background records. Its core tradeoff is more review depth against the possibility of a slower result on complex cases.

Before choosing a package, consider the records you need, current state coverage, who will pay, whether applicants will complete bank or payroll connections, and how RentPrep fits your software workflow. High-volume operators should also weigh the 50-unit threshold and commercial-office requirement.

RentPrep can support applicant evaluation, while ButterflyMX can support ongoing property entry through video intercoms, access control, mobile access, visitor access, and other access products. Explore ButterflyMX when your needs expand from tenant screening to property access and security.

butterflymx blog header image

Get your free quote!

Fill in the form below, and we'll email you right back.

Want a free quote?

Fill in the form below, and we'll email you right back.

Director of Content
Katie joined the team at ButterflyMX in 2022, where she started as a Content Writer before working her way up to Director of Content. With an educational background in English and a love for SEO, Katie is passionate about writing content that educates people while being easy to digest.

Prior to joining ButterflyMX, Katie worked as a political marketing copywriter, where she wrote for political candidates and officeholders, including Federal and State Representatives, Federal and State Senators, a former Vice President, two former Speakers of the House, and several federal committees. Her work has been featured in American Camp Association, Meniscus Literary Journal, and 45th Parallel Literary Magazine.

Katie graduated from the University of Texas in 2017 and Texas State University’s Creative Writing MFA in 2020. She lives in Dallas, Texas with her dog, Ziggy, where you can catch her walking on the Katy Trail, rooting for the Longhorns during college football season, and hunting local bookstores for her next read.